Weight loss supplements: scam or real help for slimming down? Discover the truth!

Jeux paralympiques

Dietary supplements can be a valuable aid during a diet, but it’s important to choose the right ones. Proteins help preserve muscle mass and improve satiety, while omega-3s regulate inflammation and promote better fat management. Fibers help stabilize appetite and improve digestion, while certain vitamins and minerals (vitamin D, magnesium, zinc) prevent common deficiencies during a calorie deficit. Finally, green tea and caffeine can slightly increase metabolism and boost energy. However, these supplements do not replace a balanced diet or an active lifestyle. Discover in detail how to effectively integrate them into your weight loss program!

TABLE OF CONTENTS

DO “MIRACLE” PRODUCTS REALLY HELP YOU LOSE WEIGHT?

With the rise of the dietary supplement market, many products claim to promote rapid and effortless weight loss. Fat burners, appetite suppressants, metabolism boosters... But are these claims scientifically proven?



THE PROMISE OF RAPID WEIGHT LOSS: A MYTH?

Most miracle products in dieting are based on an enticing idea: losing weight easily, without dieting or exercise. However, science shows that sustainable weight loss primarily relies on a caloric deficit, meaning consuming fewer calories than daily energy expenditure. No supplement can replace this fundamental principle.



POPULAR INGREDIENTS AND THEIR SCIENTIFIC LIMITATIONS.

Some active ingredients are often highlighted for their supposed effectiveness:

  • Caffeine and green tea: Slightly stimulate metabolism and thermogenesis, but their effect remains moderate without dietary adjustments.
  • CLA (conjugated linoleic acid): Suspected of influencing fat distribution, but studies on its effectiveness are contradictory.
  • L-carnitine: Involved in transporting fats to the mitochondria, but its role in supplementation is limited without physical activity.
  • Chitosan: Presented as a fat blocker, but studies show that its effect on fat absorption is negligible.



THE LIMITATIONS OF STUDIES ON THESE PRODUCTS.

Many studies on these ingredients are funded by the dietary supplement industry, which can bias the results. Moreover, studies showing a positive effect often demonstrate modest results, far less significant than those achieved with a balanced diet and regular physical activity.



SIDE EFFECTS AND HEALTH RISKS.

Some products can have undesirable effects:

  • Palpitations and insomnia (related to caffeine and stimulants).
  • Digestive issues (with fat blockers or appetite suppressants).
  • Dietary imbalances due to overly restrictive diets.



THE ONLY APPROACH THAT WORKS: DIET AND LIFESTYLE.

Experts agree that the best way to lose weight sustainably is based on three pillars:

  • A balanced, calorie-controlled diet.
  • Regular physical activity.
  • Restorative sleep and good stress management.

Dietary supplements can be a temporary aid, but they will never replace these fundamentals.

No miracle product allows you to lose weight without effort. Before purchasing a weight loss supplement, it's essential to check the scientific evidence and avoid solutions that seem too good to be true. A sustainable and healthy approach remains the key to successful weight loss.

WHAT ARE THE MOST COMMON INGREDIENTS USED IN THESE PRODUCTS?

Weight loss supplements often contain ingredients marketed as fat burners or metabolism boosters. But are they really effective? Here is an overview of the most common substances and their actual effects.



CAFFEINE: A STIMULANT WITH LIMITED EFFECTS.

Caffeine is one of the most used ingredients in weight loss products. It works by stimulating the nervous system, thus increasing thermogenesis (heat production) and energy expenditure.

  • Positive effects: Can slightly improve fat oxidation and give a boost to training.
  • Limitations: The effect is moderate and temporary. In excess, it can cause palpitations, insomnia, and anxiety.



GREEN TEA: AN ANTIOXIDANT WITH MODEST BENEFITS.

Green tea contains catechins and caffeine, which together may increase fat burning.

  • Positive effects: Can help improve energy expenditure and promote fat oxidation.
  • Limitations: Its effect is weak without an adapted diet and physical activity.



CLA (CONJUGATED LINOLEIC ACID): A PROMISE UNFULFILLED.

CLA is a fatty acid often touted for its ability to reduce body fat and increase muscle mass.

  • Positive effects: Some studies show a minimal reduction in body fat, but CLA remains an important substance for improving health due to its action on the immune system and its anti-inflammatory properties.
  • Limitations: The results are too weak to be significant, and side effects such as digestive issues may occur.



L-CARNITINE: A FAT TRANSPORTER?

L-carnitine plays a role in transporting fatty acids to the mitochondria, where they are used as an energy source.

  • Positive effects: Can be useful in case of deficiency, particularly in vegetarians. Its effect is directly noticeable.
  • Limitations: No proven effect on weight loss in people with a normal diet. Therefore, it should be combined with exercise and a suitable diet.



FORSKOLIN: A MOLECULE WITH UNCERTAIN EFFECTIVENESS.

Derived from the Coleus forskohlii plant, forskolin is supposed to activate an enzyme that promotes fat breakdown.

  • Positive effects: Some studies suggest a slight effect on body composition.
  • Limitations: Too little solid scientific evidence to base weight loss solely on its action.



OTHER COMMON INGREDIENTS AND THEIR REALITIES.

  • Chitosan: Marketed as a fat blocker, but its effectiveness is negligible. However, a change in stools is often observed.
  • Exotic fruit extracts (garcinia cambogia, raspberry ketone): Little to no scientifically proven effects.
  • Capsaicin (red pepper): May slightly increase thermogenesis, but its effect on weight loss is very limited.

Some of these ingredients may have a slight effect on metabolism, but none replace a proper diet and physical exercise. Most studies show that the results are minimal and often exaggerated by marketing. For effective weight loss, it is better to focus on an approach based on diet and lifestyle rather than relying on miracle solutions. In general, fat burners are a HELP, not the foundation of progress. The most important things remain diet and exercise!

WHY ARE THESE PRODUCTS OFTEN CRITICIZED?

Miracle products in dieting are often criticized for several reasons. Between side effects, exaggerated promises, and lack of scientific evidence, they provoke numerous critiques. Here's why it's essential to approach them with caution.



SOMETIMES DANGEROUS SIDE EFFECTS.

Some weight loss supplements contain substances that can cause unwanted side effects, especially when they are poorly dosed or taken over the long term.

  • Excessive stimulation: Products containing caffeine or synephrine can lead to palpitations, high blood pressure, and sleep disturbances.
  • Digestive issues: Appetite suppressants and fat binders can cause bloating, diarrhea, or poor nutrient absorption.
  • Hormonal imbalances: Some ingredients affect hormonal metabolism, potentially disrupting the body's natural balance.

In extreme cases, banned substances have been found in some supplements (unauthorized stimulants, doping substances), putting consumers' health at risk.



DECEPTIVE AND EXAGGERATED MARKETING.

The promises made by manufacturers of these products are often too good to be true.

  • Weight loss without effort? Nothing replaces a calorie deficit and a healthy lifestyle.
  • Guaranteed results? Every individual reacts differently, and the effects may be minimal, or even nonexistent.
  • Misleading before/after photos: Many advertisements use retouched photos or biased testimonials to sell their products.

Some brands also rely on the placebo effect: by consuming a product supposedly designed to aid weight loss, some people unknowingly adopt a healthier lifestyle, thus skewing the actual results of the supplement.



LACK OF SOLID SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE?

Many ingredients used in these products have not undergone rigorous and independent studies.

  • Industry-funded studies: Some positive results are biased because they come directly from supplement manufacturers.
  • Insignificant results: Even when studies show efficacy, the effects are often very weak and don't justify the investment.
  • Lack of scientific consensus: The few positive results are not always reproducible, which limits their reliability.

Thus, no serious study proves that a supplement alone leads to sustainable and significant weight loss without dietary and exercise changes.

Weight loss products are often criticized because they sell a dream rather than real effectiveness. Between side effects, lack of solid scientific evidence, and misleading marketing, it is essential to adopt a critical approach. The only real solution for sustainable weight loss remains a healthy lifestyle, combining a balanced diet and regular physical activity.

WHAT ARE THE RISKS OF FAT BURNERS AND APPETITE SUPPRESSANTS?

Fat burners and appetite suppressants are supplements commonly used to accelerate weight loss. However, their consumption is not without risks. Many users report side effects, sometimes severe, which can impact long-term health. Here are the main dangers to know before consuming them.



DIGESTIVE TROUBLES: A DISTURBANCE OF THE INTESTINAL SYSTEM

Some fat burners and fat blockers work by blocking fat absorption or increasing metabolism. As a result, the digestive system can be heavily disrupted.

  • Diarrhea and bloating: Some supplements prevent fat absorption, which can lead to oily stools and difficult digestion.
  • Abdominal pain: Excessive stimulation of metabolism can cause cramps and gastric discomfort.
  • Nausea and acid reflux: Some irritating ingredients, like chili or caffeine, can worsen acid reflux and digestive discomfort.



PALPITATIONS AND CARDIAC TROUBLES: A REAL RISK

Many fat burners contain stimulants (caffeine, synephrine, theobromine, etc.), which increase thermogenesis and heart rate. But this effect can quickly become dangerous.

  • Tachycardia and palpitations: Over-stimulation of the nervous system can cause irregular heartbeats, chest tightness, and dizziness.
  • High blood pressure: The increase in metabolism can also raise blood pressure, increasing the risk of cardiovascular diseases.
  • Increased risk of heart attacks: In predisposed individuals, excessive consumption of stimulants can lead to heart attacks or strokes.



EFFECTS ON METABOLISM: LONG-TERM CONSEQUENCES

Prolonged use of fat burners or appetite suppressants can disrupt the natural functioning of metabolism and the hormonal system.

  • Dependence on stimulants: Overstimulating metabolism with substances like caffeine causes the body to adapt and lose effectiveness. As a result, higher doses are needed to feel an effect.
  • Risk of yo-yo effect: By artificially suppressing appetite, these products prevent long-term dietary re-education. Once the supplement is stopped, appetite returns with force, which can lead to rapid weight regain.
  • Hormonal imbalance: Some ingredients affect the production of hormones involved in hunger and satiety, which can disrupt metabolism in the long term.



RISK OF PSYCHOLOGICAL TROUBLES: AN UNBALANCED RELATIONSHIP WITH FOOD

Appetite suppressants and fat burners can also have a negative impact on mental well-being.

  • Anxiety and nervousness: Stimulants can cause overactivity of the nervous system, leading to stress, irritability, and insomnia.
  • Frustration and psychological dependence: By artificially suppressing hunger, these products can create dependence, where the user fears they cannot lose weight without them.
  • Altered food perception: By trying to control hunger at all costs, some consumers develop a fear of food, leading to eating disorders (ED).

Fat burners and appetite suppressants promise rapid weight loss, but the side effects can be serious. Between digestive issues, heart impact, and disruption of metabolism, these products should be consumed with extreme caution, always in combination with a balanced diet and appropriate physical activity. For sustainable and safe weight loss, nothing beats an approach based on good eating habits and a healthy lifestyle.

ARE THERE ANY NATURAL PRODUCTS THAT ACTUALLY WORK?

Faced with growing mistrust toward industrial weight loss supplements, many consumers are turning to natural alternatives to support weight loss. But do certain foods and natural substances truly impact weight management? Here’s an overview of the most promising options.



APPLE CIDER VINEGAR: AN INTERESTING DIGESTIVE AID.

Long used in traditional medicine, apple cider vinegar is often cited as a slimming ally.

  • Appetite reduction: It can slow gastric emptying, thus increasing the feeling of fullness.
  • Blood sugar regulation: It helps stabilize blood sugar levels, which can limit cravings.
  • Limitations: Its effect on weight loss remains moderate and only works within the context of a balanced diet. Excessive consumption may cause digestive issues and damage tooth enamel.



SOLUBLE FIBER: ENHANCED SATIETY.

Soluble fibers (found in oats, legumes, chia seeds, etc.) are known for their beneficial effects on metabolism.

  • Natural appetite suppressant: They form a gel in the stomach that slows digestion and prolongs the feeling of fullness.
  • Blood sugar regulation: They help reduce insulin spikes after meals, thus preventing cravings.
  • Improved intestinal transit: They promote healthy digestion and better waste elimination.
  • Limitations: Excessive consumption may cause bloating and digestive discomfort.



PROTEINS: A KEY TOOL FOR BODY COMPOSITION.

Proteins (lean meats, fish, eggs, legumes, whey…) play a key role in weight management.

  • Thermogenic effect: Digesting protein requires more energy than digesting carbohydrates or fats, thus increasing calorie expenditure.
  • Muscle mass preservation: They help reduce muscle loss during a calorie deficit.
  • Prolonged satiety: They help avoid snacking and sugar cravings.
  • Limitations: Excessive protein intake without appropriate physical activity does not guarantee weight loss and can strain the kidneys over the long term.



GREEN TEA AND COFFEE: METABOLISM BOOSTERS.

These natural beverages are often highlighted for their thermogenic properties.

  • Increased energy expenditure: Thanks to caffeine and catechins, they slightly stimulate the metabolism.
  • Improved fat mobilization: They facilitate the use of fat as an energy source.
  • Limitations: The effect remains modest and depends on individual sensitivity to caffeine. In excess, they may cause sleep disturbances and anxiety.



SPICES (CHILI, TURMERIC, CINNAMON): A SMALL METABOLIC BOOST.

Certain spices are known for their effects on metabolism and digestion.

  • Increased thermogenesis: Red chili, for instance, can slightly boost calorie expenditure.
  • Anti-inflammatory effect: Turmeric and cinnamon help reduce inflammation, which is often linked to weight gain.
  • Limitations: The effect on weight loss is minimal and does not replace a balanced diet.

Some natural products can give a helpful boost in weight management, particularly by regulating appetite and improving metabolism. However, none of them are a miracle solution. To achieve lasting results, it is essential to incorporate them into a holistic approach that includes a balanced diet and regular physical activity.

HOW CAN YOU SPOT AN INEFFECTIVE OR DANGEROUS PRODUCT?

With the multitude of dietary supplements on the market, it can be difficult to distinguish an effective product from one that is useless—or even dangerous. However, certain signs can help you spot scams and avoid marketing traps. Here are the main red flags to watch out for before buying a weight loss supplement.



EXAGGERATED PROMISES: AN IMMEDIATE RED FLAG.

Ineffective or questionable products are often promoted with marketing claims that are too good to be true.

  • "Lose 10 kg in one month without effort!" Rapid weight loss without dieting is unrealistic and often dangerous.
  • "100% effective fat burner, scientifically proven!" Be wary of claims not backed by independent studies.
  • "Guaranteed immediate effect!" Weight loss is a gradual process—no product works overnight.



A HIDDEN OR SUSPICIOUS INGREDIENT LIST.

A supplement’s label should clearly state the ingredients and their dosages. Some products hide ineffective or dangerous substances behind vague formulations.

  • No precise dosages: Terms like "proprietary blend" or "secret formula" are often used to conceal a lack of effectiveness.
  • Presence of strong stimulants: Some fat burners contain high doses of caffeine, synephrine, or yohimbine, which can cause severe side effects (palpitations, anxiety, insomnia).
  • Banned ingredients: Some weight loss supplements have been pulled from the market due to banned substances (like ephedrine or DNP, which are dangerous for the heart).



NO RELIABLE SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE.

A credible product should be supported by solid scientific studies, conducted on a significant sample and published in reputable journals.

  • In-house studies funded by the brand: A conflict of interest may skew the results.
  • Lack of verifiable sources: A product that cites no serious scientific references is suspicious.
  • Testimonials instead of proof: Customer reviews and dramatic before/after photos are often used to hide the lack of scientific evidence.



AN EXORBITANT PRICE FOR AN ORDINARY PRODUCT.

Some dietary supplements are sold at excessive prices even though their ingredients are common and inexpensive.

  • Very high price without scientific justification: Beware of products sold as “revolutionary” when they contain only basic ingredients.
  • Forced subscriptions: Some unscrupulous brands offer free trials but automatically enroll you in a monthly subscription that’s hard to cancel.



MISSING OR INCOMPLETE HEALTH WARNINGS.

A serious product should clearly state any potential side effects and contraindications.

  • No usage precautions: The absence of warnings for pregnant women, people on medication, or high-level athletes is a bad sign.
  • No overdose warnings: Some ingredients, like caffeine or green tea, can be harmful in excessive amounts.
  • No quality certification: Look for labels such as GMP (Good Manufacturing Practices) or ISO, which ensure a certain level of safety.

Before buying a weight loss supplement, take the time to analyze its label, ingredients, and marketing claims. Be wary of miracle products and prioritize those backed by solid scientific evidence. Finally, if in doubt, consult a healthcare professional before adding a new supplement to your routine.

WHAT ARE THE BEST SUPPLEMENTS TO SUPPORT A HEALTHY DIET?

When well chosen, certain dietary supplements can be a real asset for optimizing weight loss or maintaining nutritional balance during a diet. But which ones are truly effective? Here are the supplements that can help without falling into marketing traps.



PROTEINS: A PILLAR FOR PRESERVING MUSCLE MASS.

During a diet, it is essential to maintain sufficient protein intake to prevent muscle loss.

  • Satiating effect: Proteins prolong the feeling of fullness and reduce snacking urges.
  • Preservation of muscle mass: In a calorie deficit, they help minimize muscle loss.
  • Increased energy expenditure: Digesting protein requires more energy than digesting carbohydrates or fats.
  • Recommended: Whey protein, casein, plant-based proteins (pea, rice, soy).



OMEGA-3s: A SUPPORT FOR HEALTH AND METABOLISM.

These essential fatty acids, mainly found in fatty fish and certain plant oils, are beneficial for both weight loss and overall health.

  • Inflammation regulation: Chronic inflammation can slow down weight loss.
  • Improved insulin sensitivity: Promotes better fat and carbohydrate management.
  • Appetite suppressant effect: Helps stabilize appetite and reduce cravings.
  • Recommended: Fish oil supplements, krill oil, plant-based omega-3s (flaxseed, chia).



VITAMINS AND MINERALS: AVOIDING DEFICIENCIES.

A restrictive diet can lead to deficiencies in vitamins and minerals essential for proper body function.

  • Vitamin D: Essential for metabolism and bone health, often deficient in sedentary individuals.
  • Magnesium: Helps manage stress and improves sleep quality—two key factors for effective weight loss.
  • Zinc and chromium: Play a role in blood sugar regulation and managing sugar cravings.
  • Recommended: Well-dosed multivitamins, specific supplements if a deficiency is confirmed.



FIBERS: FOR BETTER SATIETY AND DIGESTION.

Fibers play a key role in digestion and appetite control.

  • Natural appetite suppressant: They slow down digestion and provide long-lasting satiety.
  • Blood sugar regulation: They help prevent insulin spikes that trigger cravings.
  • Improved intestinal transit: Essential for smooth digestion and effective waste elimination.
  • Recommended: Psyllium, inulin, glucomannan, chia and flax seeds.



GREEN TEA AND CAFFEINE: A SLIGHT BOOST TO METABOLISM.

These natural substances can give a slight boost to energy expenditure.

  • Increased metabolism: Caffeine and green tea catechins may enhance calorie burning.
  • Improved fat oxidation: They promote the use of fat as an energy source.
  • Energy boost for training: Caffeine improves focus and sports performance.
  • Limitations: The effect is moderate and may cause sleep disturbances if consumed in excess.
  • Recommended: Green tea extract, black coffee, guarana, maté.

Dietary supplements can be a valuable aid in optimizing a diet, but they do not replace a balanced diet and a healthy lifestyle. Proteins, omega-3s, vitamins, fibers, and certain natural stimulants can provide support, provided they are well chosen and used wisely.

COACH'S TIPS

  • Never rely solely on a product for your results. The most important thing is maintaining a good lifestyle and tracking progress. However, certain products can support a well-balanced diet and fitness regimen.

  • Never underestimate the placebo effect! Knowing you've invested in a product that works often pushes you to train harder and eat better. The effort you put in engages you on a path where you’ll want to do more, leading to better results.

  • At QNT, our products are regulated by the AFSCA, which ensures that we don’t make unrealistic promises.

  • Therefore, it's safe to say that without a foundation of training and proper nutrition, no product is miraculous and cannot deliver results without a minimum of effort.

Yves Bondroit coach for QNT

Posted in: Our tips

Back to blog

Related posts

Blog navigation

Blog categories

View all categories

Popular posts

View all popular posts